Rent vs. buy calculator
Find out whether renting or buying leaves you with more money after a given number of years — and when buying starts to pay off.
Buying
Renting & investing
Year-by-year comparison
Net worth if you sold the home (after selling costs) in each year, compared with what a renter would have invested. Your chosen stay is in bold.
| Year | Buyer net worth | Renter net worth | Ahead |
|---|
Rough sheet
step-by-stepIs it better to rent or buy?
There is no universal answer, because the right choice depends on how long you will stay, how much homes appreciate where you live, what the mortgage costs, and what you would do with your money if you did not buy. The common mistake is comparing a mortgage payment to rent and stopping there. Buying has costs that never show up in the payment — property tax, insurance, maintenance, closing costs and selling costs — and renting has a benefit that is easy to overlook: the cash you do not spend on a down payment can be invested. This calculator puts both sides on equal footing.
How the comparison works
Both people start with the same cash. The buyer spends it on the down payment and closing costs; the renter invests it. Every month, whoever has the lower housing cost invests the difference. The buyer's monthly cost is the mortgage payment plus property tax, insurance and maintenance. The renter's cost is rent, which rises each year at the growth rate you enter. After the number of years you choose, the buyer sells the home, pays selling costs and the remaining loan balance, and keeps any savings. The renter holds the investment portfolio. Whoever ends with more net worth wins.
A worked example
With the default inputs — a $400,000 home, 20% down, a 6.5% rate on a 30-year loan, 3% appreciation, $2,200 monthly rent and a 6% investment return — owning costs about $2,873 in the first month versus $2,200 in rent. After 7 years the buyer's net worth is about $173,000 and the renter's is about $197,000, so renting is ahead by roughly $24,000. The two lines cross in year 13, and after 15 years buying leads by about $14,700. In other words, with these numbers a short stay favors renting and a long stay favors buying.
What shifts the break-even point
Three inputs move the result more than anything else. Appreciation is the biggest: at 0% growth the buyer never catches up in this example, while at 5% the break-even drops to year 4. Rent is next — at $2,800 a month instead of $2,200 the break-even also falls to year 4, because the gap between rent and the cost of owning shrinks. The mortgage rate matters too: at 5.5% instead of 6.5%, break-even arrives around year 7. These are single-variable changes from the defaults; try them yourself and watch the year-by-year table respond.
What this calculator leaves out
Every model simplifies. This one does not include the federal mortgage interest deduction, because many households take the standard deduction instead, and it does not model capital gains exclusions on the sale of a primary home. It also does not account for non-financial factors: stability, freedom to renovate, the flexibility of renting, or the risk of moving sooner than planned. A rule of thumb is that buying rarely makes sense if you expect to stay fewer than five years, because closing and selling costs take years of appreciation and principal payments to recover. To work out how much home your income can support, use the Home Affordability Calculator, and for a detailed payment breakdown see the Mortgage Calculator. Results are estimates, not financial advice.
Frequently asked questions
Common questions about this calculator.
It depends on appreciation, rent, the mortgage rate and your costs. Many scenarios break even somewhere between five and ten years, because closing and selling costs take time to recover. This calculator shows your own break-even year.
Because the cash a buyer spends on the down payment and closing costs could otherwise be invested, and because the cheaper option each month leaves extra money to invest. Ignoring this makes buying look better than it really is.
No. Many households take the standard deduction instead of itemizing, so the deduction does not help them. If you do itemize, your actual result for buying may be somewhat better than shown.
It varies widely by city and decade. Long-run national averages are often cited in the range of a few percent a year, but local markets can be far higher or lower. Try several values, including 0%, to see how sensitive your result is.
Closing costs are the lender, title and other fees paid when you buy, often a few percent of the price. Selling costs are mainly the agent commissions and fees paid when you sell, commonly around 5–6% of the price. Both reduce what you keep.
Treat it as a way to compare scenarios rather than a prediction. Change the appreciation, rent growth and return assumptions and look at the range of outcomes before deciding.